The secret to a perfect boil is adding the ingredients in order so nothing gets mushy or overcooked.
-
Season the Water In a very large pot, bring the 5 quarts of water and the Old Bay to a rolling boil.
-
The Potatoes (20 Minutes) Add the potatoes. Cover and boil for about 15 to 20 minutes until they are just starting to get fork-tender.
-
The Sausage and Corn (10 Minutes) Add the sausage chunks and the corn pieces. Continue boiling for 10 more minutes.
-
The Shrimp (3 Minutes) Add the shrimp. Stir them in and cook for only 2 to 3 minutes. As soon as they turn pink and opaque, they are done. Do not overcook them or they will be hard to peel!
-
Drain and Serve Drain the water immediately. Dump the whole mix onto a large platter (or a newspaper-lined table).
Pro-Tips
-
The Shrimp: Use “easy-peel” shrimp (already deveined but with the shell on). The shells protect the meat and soak up the seasoning.
-
The “Boil” Flavor: If you want it even more authentic, add a whole onion (halved) and a head of garlic (top sliced off) to the water at the very beginning.
-
The Finish: Squeeze the lemon wedges over everything while it’s steaming hot and serve with individual bowls of melted butter for dipping.
3 Rules for the Best Boil
-
Don’t Skimp on Spice: If the water doesn’t look dark orange from the seasoning, add more. The food only spends a few minutes in the water, so it needs to be punchy.
-
Potatoes First: Always start with the potatoes. They take the longest.
-
Ice Cold Beer: This is the traditional drink to serve alongside a spicy boil.
ADVERTISEMENT